Ok, many consider the bill has something wrong within it so the teacher are protesting against it but its a huge NO. Neither is the reason that local government will be involved but the reasons are;
1. Thousands of teachers were posted for position “Karar/Aasthai” (Position that doesn’t require qualification and licence exam) (Yi sab SLC barely pass wa fail ka hun). In simple laguage, it means job for a temporary period of time with no provision of pension and these karar/aasthai position are acquired through political leaders and parties not through competitions. Although, to be a teacher you need to get license but karar don’t require it but now according to this bill they can no longer practice teaching and have to go through licensing exam but they don’t want fair competition as they are incapable to compete. They just want all those incapable fools “karar” to be made “Thai” teachers with the facitliy of pension till they die (to pay them more 40 years) which is a major concern as our country is in no position to pay these assholes.
2. Ok now most are in karar but what if they acquired licence during their teaching period as karar? Like okay some did karar position for 12 years and acquired licence after teaching 12 years. Now, their wish is they want themselves to be considered permanent teacher(thai) during all those 12 years too although they were as asthai. Why? Because it would increase the pension significantly and its not just paying them for 1 or 2 year but till they die which might be more than 40 years from now. Like wtf.
3. Bachelors degree has been made compulsory and many do not have it (nearly 70-80% and thats a lot) as some are teaching from Panchayat or Monarchy and in that time attending till class 10 was an achievement in itself. So, most of the karar are 10 class barely pass. SLC “Falame dhoka” bhanu ko reason yehi ho as SLC was gate to most of the government position in that time but now it doesn’t even matters so even dismantling SEE should not be a concern.
4. Making local government to control public school was mentioned in the constitution itself. So, they are not here for it but the above mentioned 3 reasons. As, to change it from local government to federal government you have to amend the constitution itself with 2/3 rd majority (which is impossible) as it comes under the 20 or something power provided to the local government.
So, by no means these jerks are good but rather here for selfish reasons and the bill to be passed is highly standard and trying to change education system by a good percentage.
If you have little bit of brain then you might have thought this thoroughly instead of insulting the teacher.
They have been teaching grade 1 to 10 for more than 10 years and now they want to take exam consistenting bachelor and master degree to make thai. Are yoh seriously saying its fair. Can you remember anything from your last year studies?
At that time SLC was huge achievement and after that comes experience what makes them unqualified to teach grade 1 to 5. Does your brain fail to comprehend this. Will you work for mesaly salary of teaching grade 1 after completing bachelor degree?
And what about those who have bachelor degree or master degree why dont they have thai position? I dont think one can pass masters degree just by luck and shit.
And who said they are not here because of your 4th point. Just because you asked some guillable people and think everyone is like that.
If they want to change it should be for new teacher not the old teacher who has been teaching for more than 10 years, what will they do now after being this old.
Think a little from their perspective before you insult them. Its just pathetic
I disagree. Karar bhaneko contract ma hire gareko lai bhancha. Yo job haru requirement anusar school le hire garne ho yessai manlagdi ghusaune haina. Permanent job lai exam diyera ladnu parcha, tara problem ka nira cha bhane alli ramro thau ma competition dherai nai cha ra remote area ma thai bhayera jana kam mache haru nai manchan. so only option huncha karaar ma teacher hire garne ra tyo praye jaso tei thau ko locals hunthe/hunchan.
​
Nepal ma manche padnu parcha bhanne sikeko dherai bhako chaina, hami bhanda agadi ko generation ma padne manche haru kam nai hunthe. ajai bachelor/masters garne ta dherai nai kam ra gareko manche haru pani government ko aru nai ramro job garthe teaching ta kam le nai garthe. Aba school haru badna lagepachi teacher haru rakhna paryo ani aba padekai manche haru kam thiye. Qualifications bhanda pani jolai jati aaucha padaune, afu pani padne, experience pani baddai janthyo, tesari nai chalirako thiyo. It was atleast better than to not have teacher at all.
Aja bhanda 2,3 decades agadi ko country ko situation ra ahile ko time ma dherai farak cha. Ahile karar ma pani qualifications chaincha, 12 pass garera 10 padauna paudainau, tei primary level lai nai ho padaune. Aaba sabai jana ko case yehi chai nahola, kunai politcal appointment holan, koi le kaam nagari talab khane medium pani banaye hola. Tara sabai lai eutai bracket ma rakhera ‘cunts’, ‘assholes’ , ‘jerks’ bhannu ani education sector ma yetro contribute gareko teacher haru ko work lai dismiss garnu kati ko thik hola? khub educated ra qualifications ko kura garne le, afnai education lai question garne ki?
​
Maoist insurgency ko bela ma war area ma padaune teacher cunts ho? Remote area ma jaha manche haru dui din gayera basna sakdaina, testo thau ma decades samma teaching job garne le chai desh ko lagi kei gareko chainan? tetro work gareko manche lai government le pension dinu ramro kura haina ra? yo problem aaja ayera ayera discuss garne haina, bistarai improve gardai janu parthyo pahilei bata. Long term kasaile sochenan, education sector ma k kami cha future ma kasto hola bhanera dimag ma kasaiko aayena, decade agadi bata planning garera improve gardai janu parne thiyo tara kasailai matlab bhayena. Ahile ta narrative nai teacher haru bad ani nepal ko education nai teacher haru le garera bigareko bhanne garako chan, which is wrong.
Bro thank you for exposing them and also thank you for explaining this good.
And I thought all of those were liscenced teachers. Bachelors should be bare minimum to be a teacher really.
Noone hates the development of Nepal more than these political parties ko jhole karyakarta.
in nepal there is no such thing as research or critical thinking. tesai teacher haru ko maag sambodhan garnuaprcha re ajha! these people are political goons who want to get facilites equivalent to a government officer without even giving competitive exams like loksewaa. third division ma slc pass vayeko haruko jimmma ma chha sabai public school. behaal chha jata tatai
the thing i don’t understand local government pani government nai haina? local government bata badmashi huncha vane accountabilty khojne ho. sabai sangh antargat vaye kina sanghiyata chahiyeko thiyo? karnali ko bikat gaau ko public school laai pani sangh le hernuparne ani kathmandu ko laai pani sangh le nai hernuparne?
aile ko pass huna lageko bill ekdam ramro cha. government le maitighar ma ufreko var ma compromise garna mildaina. chase these people away.
Tyo uniharuko associationko main goal nai yehi ho… esaiko laagi banayeko ho yo association…uniharule agadi dekhinai yo demand gareyko thiyo sarkarlai I think about 3 yrs ago… permanent banauna paryo vanera…
Aile aayeko bill trigger point vayo local government ma rakhney clause Lai issue banayera they are indirectly at the streets to fulfill their main demand…yo vayo vaney already debt ridden govt lai ajai debt burden huncha and it will grow as well…
jhan pension ni chaiyo, budho haru lai.
​
tara some points like giving powers fully to ward head is valid, testo ka paincha. sichak sewa le aafno hath ma liye ramro.
The amount of brain damage in this comment section is amazing.
and i heard simple exam line ra pass vaye thai garne and most of them failed.
well said op 👏
Ho ta hau.
Take a moment and recall some of your teacher out there who was ‘karar’ and ‘cunt’.(I can easily remember couple of them from my side).
They joined without any hassle ..which is through so called exam(Question are leaked to those who are around power).
Those karar cunts were and are out there chilling..
So this bill shall regulate them.
To get some quality teachers via centralized license exam this is must.
Those cunts should be sweeped off..
“ MY LADS..Kassam..Teachers haru ta ramroo nai hunuparxa…You know how good and bad teachers are like and the consequences they bring with them..Sakdo best teachers haru should get chance. Let’s think rationally and welcome this bill”
Again..I’m so happy that this bill is getting this much hype and everyone is talking about it..This is a very good thing..I hope more homework will be done regarding this and passed for everyone’s good sake..
Let’s not get driven by sentiments..So Drastic regulations like this is must bhanni kuro lauxa malai ta..
bro explained it like a champ
Those fkers
Thank you for explaining hope u are unbiased…
h
Im super teacher hater, i think it is unethical to become teacher in this shit system and support this system which is ruining student’s life.
But as a worker, how can anyone be in karar when they have already worked for 12 years? Ani k only slc pass bhaneko? You think degree gives you knowledge? 4-5 kakchya lai padhauna kina chaiyo bachelors Masters? 12 barsa samma tei slc pass le chalni ani aile ayera hunna bhanna kaa painxa ta? Sure they need to upgrade themselves, tara yo bhandai ma fone fale jasto falera naya lyaune bhanne hudaina.. they are humans, proper training should be provided to them. Saman fale jasto falna mildaina. Ani pension khayera k bho ta?? Afno life ko youth deko haru le pension khada k bho ta.. purba khaai k ko baan raja le 100 jana manxe ko pension khaira xa… point is workers haru lai ramro treat garna parxa, proper law banauna parxa sabbai lai milne khale, jaa niski ja sukai jaa bhanne khalko hunu hudaina..
Afno point of view rakhna sakinxa, tara savyata vanne ni chij hunxa ni hau. Jerks, barely SLC pass are 🤦♂️. Teti bela ko SLC lai nai thulo maninthyo. Hamra bau le 43 saal ma 68% lyara SLC pass gareka, patrika ma photo ako thiyo are. Aile euta galli ma 4 jana ko 4 GPA hunxa.
Kura rahyo andolan ko. Mero baba mami ta masta xutti manara ghar baseka xan. Tara ja vanepani yo naya ain ko thau chai dustbin mei ho
My father died without pension. Worked for more than 35 years as an asthai teacher. He had a bachelors degree back then when people very rarely got one.
Apparently, the headmaster at the time snuck another person where my father should have been.
Sad thing is, he taught where he studied. He could have been so much more.
I don’t know what wrong with the current bill and what’s right and I don’t want to go there.
Where I want to go is
1. As a teacher if you are not teaching what will your students learn? You can go to the road if there are things you don’t want or you don’t like?
2. Now, what will student do when the school don’t do things as they want? Riots ??
Is that something what a student should learn from a teacher.
I understand their concern. I understand they are not satisfied with the bill that the government has brought into their field but do they have right deprive the students from their right to education?
Apart from everything if they were doing pen down and conducting regular school at least next generation would learn this is how we can protest. Right? But no. Roads and riots has every solutions.
If you are not in the class you should be you are fired. Your job is to teach students you should teach. If not you can quit your job.
This would be my approach.